2019-02-07 Meeting notes EiB Polyploid Working Group

Date

Feb 7, 2019

Participants

 

Unable to attend:

Arnaud, Elizabeth (Bioversity-France) <e.arnaud@cgiar.org>; Lindqvist-Kreuze, Hannele (CIP) <h.lindqvist-kreuze@cgiar.org>; Dreher, Kate (CIMMYT) <K.Dreher@cgiar.org>;

Added Abhishek

Goals

  • To submit an EiB Module 5 Polyploid WG proposal, define CGIAR polyploid needs and plan an in-person meeting at CIP

Discussion topics

Time

Item

Presenter

Notes

Time

Item

Presenter

Notes

 

Fill out Working group proposal

 

  • Focus on the technical pipeline for polyploids from genotyping needs, variant calling, data management, and making maps, to downstream analysis GWAS and GS for breeding.

    In the upstream analysis space there are lots of tools - mainly need to be assembled in a common place eg toolbox / Galaxy portal

    Need more focus on developing/understanding downstream tools and statistics - GS and GWAS.

    Add request for conference sponsorship to proposal

    Can also request funding through EiB module 5 sabbatical program




Confirm dates for polyploid in-person meeting at CIP: weeks of April 8th or May 6th




There is another meeting at CIP this week - on bioinformatics - training meeting for LAs 'exploring biodiversity through bioinformatics'. 9-12th april (4 days) with many overlapping attendess. May need to move to May dates - 6th. Or have the meeting after the bioinformatics training?

  • For May dates won't have field experiments - there may be one experiment still worth viewing. GOBii team is OK with either dates.

 

Contact for in-person meeting

 

Dorcas Gemenet will coordinate meeting - from Nairobi!

  • Sandra MONTAÑEZ (CIMMYT) EiB administrator - S.MONTANEZ@cgiar.org

  • Keep Hugo Campos, Kelly Robbins, Kate Dreher and Abhi Rathor copied/updated

 

Budget for in-person meeting

 

$25K? Liz will follow up with Kelly on COP total budget. Estimate costs for 12-15 people to attend from overseas.

Dorcas will get estimates for CIP costs - CIP hostels? Cost for 12-15 people for 4 nights, cost for 1-2 small meeting rooms and cost for a field trial trip

From CIP: Hannalele, Elisa, some breeders, small cost

 

Additional attendees

 

Lindsay Clark, Ph.D., University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign

 

I recently published an R package called polyRAD, which can be used for calling genotypes from sequencing read depth in polyploids. It outputs genotype posterior probabilities, which can be helpful because of the uncertainty that is generally seen unless read depth is extremely high. My students and I are working on methods for using these probabilities in GWAS and GS. Additionally, I’m collaborating with folks at various institutions on a project called “ploidyverse” where we try to make sure our software for polyploids is interoperable. Anyway, if you would like to chat about anything or would be interested in collaboration, let me know!

 

polyRAD on GitHub: https://github.com/lvclark/polyRAD

polyRAD manuscript: https://doi.org/10.1534/g3.118.200913

ploidyverse: https://ploidyverse.github.io/index.html

 

David Byrne who is interested in such community.

Since January, I have been working to organize a structure and objectives for the Tools for Polyploid proposal that is entitled, “Tools for Polyploids: Development of a Community Resource”.

 

The project includes a Computational/Genomics group, a Breeder Validation group divided by crops (Rose, Potato, Sweetpotato, Blueberry, Blackberry and Turf) each with 1 or 2 scientists to coordinate activities for breeders of that crop, and an Outreach group that will be coordinated by a post doc and will consist of all of the PIs in the project. Each crop group will have a post doc or doctoral position to work on analysis for the crop and other crops as needed. Beyond the Validation crops we want to include breeders of other polyploid crops in the training phase of the project. The idea is to offer general training and breeding program specific consulting to guide in the development of a dataset or the analysis of an existing dataset. I have enclosed the following documents for your information.

 

Robin Buell - https://plantbiology.natsci.msu.edu/directory/robin-buell/

Has worked with David Douches lab on potato

 

Jeffery Endelman, software package ClusterCall

Jeffery Endelman (https://horticulture.wisc.edu/directory/jeffrey-endelman/) is Genomic Prediction expert as some experience in term of potato (autotetraploid). Also his program has been working to optimize genotyping (GBS) for tetraploids and making cluster calls in SNP genotypes ( R package ClusterCall was developed). I developed GWASpoly package to perform GWAS in autopolyploids ( https://doi.org/10.3835/plantgenome2015.08.0073 )

https://potatobreeding.cals.wisc.edu

 

Umesh Rosyara, software package GWASpoly

 

Haplotype construction / Phasing / imputation



Lachlan J.M. Coin, software package polyHap

https://researchers.uq.edu.au/researcher/3012

Dr. Lachlan Coin (https://researchers.uq.edu.au/researcher/3012 ) from UQ, Australia has written polyHap program that can do haplotyping in polyploids. I know he worked with potato and sweet potato in development of computational tools.

 

Linkage map construction, JHI

https://www.hutton.ac.uk/staff/christine-hackett

Software Program TetraploidMap

 

General Genetics / Genomics

Dave Douches

https://www.canr.msu.edu/people/douches_david

 

 

Antonio Augusto Franco Garcia augusto.garcia@usp.br – sugar cane genetics recommended by Hugo

 

 

Richard Finkers at WUR working in potato and who might be interested to come to CIP.

Roeland E. Voorrips https://www.wur.nl/en/Persons/Roeland-dr.ir.-RE-Roeland-Voorrips.htm



Industry partners? Potato company...Simplot (more biotech)

People in polyploid reference genome management or pangenomes?

Also need people in genotyping space so can have better methods for polyploids - - link with module 3.

 

Other ways to engage the polyploid community

Seminars at GOBii/EiB seminar series

Conference sponsorship

Sabbaticals

Slack as a communication tools

Where to store meeting notes etc?



 

Invite others outside of CGIAR and affiliates to this meeting? Yes. Can also add people as needed to the monthly meeting.

Star says have plenty open slots in GOBii/EiB seminar series we can invite people to.

Do we need a separate CGIAR meeting for polyploids as there seem to be communities already? Yes, would be good to review data types and challenges in CGIAR. But connect with other groups.

RTB have cluster 1 - to connect bioinformatics and GS in all crops - cassava, banana, etc - should connect with this group - what are their objectives. Connect via Dorcas and Hannalele

Add request for conference sponsorship to proposal to WG proposal and also request sabbatical

Slack is OK for chat - but free system only keeps 10,000 messages so need to keep meeting minutes somewhere else. Can demo at our next meeting

We can keep meeting notes in a public space - cloud version (no login needed) or add attendees to confluence site

Action items

Liz  will follow up with Kelly on COP budget and estimates for 12-15 people traveling
Liz  will follow up with Sandra and Kelly on new dates
Liz  to edit and share polyploid WG proposal with group@dorcas find dates for in-person meeting at CIP and share with group
@dorcas to estimate CIP costs for meeting in-person and share with Liz
@dorcas put together list of existing tools and needs, and communities to connect with - share with group at next meeting
@dorcas put together list of additional attendees beyond who we have - need technically minded people - and share with group
Liz will draft email to invite new attendees to WG meetings, seminar series, and in-person meeting] 
Kate Dreher will set up Slack channel for us to message within
Star Yanxin Gao  will add members of WG to Confluence sit on polyploids for longer term storage of information

Decisions